Does India require a uniform civil code 2023 – A strong study 

Theme:

The Supreme Court of India argued for the need for a standard civil code in October 2015 and stated that “This cannot be allowed, else every religion will claim that it has the authority to rule certain issues as a matter of its law.

What is Uniform Civil Code: 

• The idea of having a single set of laws that would apply to all Indian people, regardless of their religions, is known as the “uniform civil code” in India.
  

• This would imply that all personal laws, including those governing marriage, divorce, inheritance, and adoption, would be uniform across the country.

• Countries that have adopted Uniform civil codes are Saudi Arabia, Turkey, Egypt, Malaysia, Nigeria, etc. 

• A proposed law in India called the Uniform Civil Code (UCC) aims to replace the existing personal laws with a unified body of regulations that would apply to all Indian people, regardless of their religious identity. 

• The UCC is a controversial issue in India, with supporters claiming it would advance equality and secularism and opponents claiming it would interfere with some community’s religious customs.

• According to Article 44 of the Indian Constitution, “The State should endeavour to obtain for the Citizens a uniform civil code across the territory of India.”

•  Although this section of the Directive Principles of State Policy is not legally binding, it is thought to be a desirable outcome that the government needs to achieve.

The UCC bill represents an effort to carry out this objective.

What makes Article 44 crucial:

A unified civil code is required by Article 44 of the Indian Constitution, which is regarded as being important and disputed for several reasons.

First of all, it aims to ensure that all Indian people are treated equally under the law, regardless of their religion and is seen as a fundamental concept of secularism and equality.

Second, because it intends to replace the variety of personal laws already in force in India with a unified set of rules that apply to all residents, it is seen as a way of strengthening national unity.

Finally, because it touches on sensitive subjects like religion and personal beliefs, it is seen as a very political and delicate problem. Despite the constitutional mandate, this has made it challenging for succeeding administrations to take action toward creating a universal civil code.

History of Uniform civil code:

The concept of a uniform civil code in India may be traced back to the colonial period when the British issued a series of laws aimed at codifying and reforming personal laws. Following independence, the idea of a uniform civil code was included as a directive principle in the Indian Constitution, with Article 44 saying that “the State shall seek to obtain for the citizens a uniform civil code throughout the territory of India.”

Since then, the topic of a uniform civil code has been a source of dispute and debate throughout India.

Benefits of Uniform civil code:

There are several potential benefits to implementing a uniform civil code in India. Some of these include:

• Promoting equality: A uniform civil code would ensure that all citizens are treated equally under the law, regardless of their religion. This could help to reduce discrimination and biases based on religious and cultural differences.

• Promoting secularism: A uniform civil code would remove the need for separate personal laws based on religion, promoting a secular and inclusive society.

• Simplifying the legal system: A uniform civil code would simplify the legal system by replacing the current patchwork of personal laws with a single set of laws that apply to all citizens.

• Improving access to justice: A uniform civil code could improve access to justice for certain communities, especially for women and minority groups who may face discrimination under certain personal laws.

• Promoting national unity and integration: A uniform civil code could help to promote national unity and integration by eliminating the diversity of personal laws that currently exist in India.

Challenges in implementing uniform civil code:

• Religious and cultural opposition: Some religious and cultural groups may object to a UCC because they may view it as compromising with their laws and customs.

• Political criticism: The issue of a UCC is highly contentious and sensitive, and it may face opposition from political parties and organizations seeking to safeguard the interests of their voters.

• Limited legal enforceability: The execution of a UCC as a directive principle is not legally enforceable. This may make it difficult for the government to implement such a code, even if it can overcome other challenges.

• Practical challenges: There may be practical challenges involved in implementing a UCC, such as the need to overhaul existing laws and legal systems, and the need to educate and inform the public about the changes.

Conclusion:

The issue of a uniform civil code in India is a complex and controversial one, with arguments both in favour and against its implementation. Supporters argue that a uniform civil code would promote equality, secularism, and national unity, while opponents argue that it would interfere with religious practices and cultural traditions.

Implementing a uniform civil code in India would likely be a challenging process, due to the diversity of religious and cultural practices in the country, as well as the political and legal hurdles that would need to be overcome. However, if successfully implemented, it could bring about significant benefits, such as promoting equality and secularism, simplifying the legal system, and improving access to justice.

Reference :
https://www.thehindu.com/opinion/lead/india-needs-a-uniform-civil-code/article67050330.ece

For more GD Topics :

Web 3.0 – The New Decentralized Online Experience

Innovation vs Invention – Which is strong?